6 Best Rain Barrels, According to Outdoor Pros
Lower your water bill and keep your garden thriving.
Reviewed by Dan DiClericoHome Improvement & Outdoor Director
We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.
Rain barrels are one of the simplest ways to conserve water at home. They collect and store rain runoff from your roof, which you can then use to hydrate your lawn, garden or even indoor plants. During a moderate storm, a single barrel can fill up fast, giving you a ready supply of water that doesn’t cost you a dime. Whether you're looking to be more eco-conscious, save on your water bill or prep your garden for dry spells, installing a rain barrel is a smart move.
When selecting a rain barrel, consider factors such as capacity, materials, aesthetics, and ease of installation and use. Collecting rainwater is a simple process, but it all comes down to how your rain barrel performs when it's time to use it. The smallest design change can turn a barrel into a winner or a loser. To help you choose the right one, we rounded up a range of options that offer the best mix of function, durability and design.
At Good Housekeeping, we review hundreds of outdoor products annually, including smart sprinklers, lawn mowers and hose nozzles. To find the best rain barrels, we consulted in-home testers and evaluated each product based on available features and overall product ratings.
EarthMinded RainStation 45 Gallon Terracotta Rain Barrel
Pros
- Includes diverter and setup kit
- Reversible lid to display flowers
Cons
- Slightly smaller 45-gallon capacity
Capacity: 45 gallons | Colors: terracotta, black | Material: food grade HDPE resin
The EarthMinded RainStation has everything you need to get started, including tools to install the diverter, which attaches to your downspout and channels water directly into the barrel. The 45-gallon capacity is ideal for moderate rain collection in smaller spaces, and the sealed lid helps prevent mosquito breeding.
RainStation barrels feature a reversible lid that can be used to grow flowers or herbs, making your rain barrel a more attractive addition to your yard. The barrel is made from durable food grade HDPE resin and is available in natural terracotta or black. If you are seeking a rain barrel that can blend seamlessly into your garden, this model from EarthMinded is worth a look.
Pros
- Affordable option with classic look
- 100% recycled
Cons
- Food odors might be present
Capacity: 55 gallons | Colors: terracotta, black, gray | Material: re-purposed plastic
If you’re after that classic terracotta look, this resin-based option offers solid performance and a unique appearance at a great price. A 55 gallon rain barrel for under $100 is an excellent value. It also has a built-in debris screen and includes a upgraded brass spigot for long-term use.
The terracotta color blends in well with brick homes and patios, and the molded construction resists cracking and splitting. These rain barrels were originally used for overseas food transport so you may notice slight scratching or scuffs as well as food odors, which the company says will dissipate after a few full barrel filling cycles.
It’s a straightforward option with few frills, but it does the job. Note that it doesn’t include a diverter, so you’ll need to purchase that separately if desired. This is the most earth-friendly option available as you will be doing your part to keep a chunk of plastic out of the landfill.
EMSCO Group Flatback Stoneware Urn Rain Barrel
Pros
- Unique design
- Planter lid
Cons
- No spigot, just a hose
Capacity: 50 gallons | Colors: sandstone, terracotta, brown | Material: plastic
Blending function and form, the Rescue Water Urn doubles as a decorative element in your yard. The sandstone, terracotta or earth brown finish and urn shape elevate it beyond basic barrel aesthetics, and the integrated planter at the top lets you grow flowers or herbs (a weep hole at the bottom of the planter lets rainfall filter into the barrel). It also includes a diverter kit and the rain barrel can be connected to a soaker hose for convenient automatic watering of nearby plants.
This is a great option if you want your rain barrel to blend in with landscaping or garden decor. It mimics a large, beautiful pot that doesn't scream, "I'm a rain barrel" every time you look at it. The self-watering option makes this a convenient addition to any small patio or garden. There is no spigot, but that just maintains the illusion of it being a large pot.
RTS Companies Inc 50-Gallon ECO Rain Water Collection Barrel
Pros
- Flat-back design sits flush against the wall
- Can be linked with additional barrels
Cons
- Plastic spigot isn't as durable as brass or metal
Capacity: 50 gallons | Color: black | Material: 100% recycled plastic
This 50-gallon rain barrel from RTS Home Accents is a reliable, well-rounded option that balances performance, appearance and value. It features a flat-back design so it sits flush against the wall of your home, saving space while keeping a low profile.
The included plastic spigot is located low for easy bucket filling, but it is not as durable as a brass fitting. The built-in screen on top helps keep out debris and insects. We like the durable, UV-resistant polyethylene construction, which resists fading and cracking over time. The molded design gives the appearance of a classic oak barrel that may appeal to homeowners.
It also includes a threaded fitting for connecting multiple barrels, which expands its functionality. A group of two or three of these rain barrels would look great in almost any yard.
FreeGarden Rain 55 Gallon Rain Barrel with Brass Spigot
Pros
- Square design for wall or corner placement
- Elevated spigot for easier access
Cons
- Prominent logo and branding
Capacity: 55 gallons | Colors: beige, green, black | Material: plastic
The FreeGarden RAIN barrel stands out with its high-quality brass spigot and solid construction. At 55 gallons, it offers plenty of capacity while maintaining a compact footprint thanks to its flat-back design, which allows it to be used against the wall or in a corner. The child-proof lid adds extra safety, and a durable metal screen guard keeps out debris and bugs.
This barrel is especially ideal for households looking for durability and performance. It’s made from FDA-approved, BPA-free resin that is UV-stabilized to prevent fading or degradation. The branding is prominent, which might be undesirable to some users. The stable design and elevated brass spigot forego the need for a base. This rain barrel has the ability to link multiple barrels from either side using the pre-threaded ports.
FCMP Outdoor 50 Gallons Brown Recycled Plastic Rain Barrel
Pros
- Arrives ready to use, no assembly needed
- Convenient hose hanger
Cons
- No standard spigot
Capacity: 50 gallons | Colors: brown, black, gray, green | Material: Polyethylene (PE)
The FCMP Outdoor RC4000 Rain Catcher has a space-efficient, flat-back design like the RTS that makes it a good choice for placement against a wall or fence. Its contemporary look and 50-gallon capacity are appealing for urban gardeners or those with limited space.
However, it lacks a standard spigot. Instead, it uses a plastic hose and overflow tube, which our at-home tester found less convenient, especially in cold climates where these parts need to be removed and stored to avoid damage from freezing. In warmer climates, the built-in hose might be advantageous as you don't need to bend down to access a spigot, and the handy hose hanger keeps it clean and off the ground.
At just over $100 on Amazon, this rain barrel offers great value and enough features to keep most homeowners happy for years to come.
How we chose the best rain barrels
At Good Housekeeping, our selections are based on a careful review of product features, price, availability and brand reputation. We researched a wide range of rain barrels from trusted manufacturers and retailers to identify models that offer practical design, reliable performance and value for homeowners looking to conserve water.
We prioritized barrels with user-friendly features such as large capacities, overflow protection and secure lids. Spigots for easy hose attachment and diverter kits for connecting to downspouts were also key considerations. Design elements, like flat-back shapes for snug wall placement or decorative finishes that blend with outdoor decor, helped certain models stand out.
We read through customer reviews and consulted homeowners with rain barrels to understand long-term performance and common pain points, especially regarding maintenance, drainage and winter storage. Only models with consistently high marks for durability and function made our list. Whether you're new to rainwater collection or replacing an aging setup, these rain barrels represent a range of options to suit different budgets, styles and yard sizes.
What to look for in the best rain barrels
Rain barrels may seem like a simple backyard upgrade, but the right model can help you conserve water, manage storm runoff and reduce your utility bills. Here’s what to look for when choosing one:
✔️ Capacity: Most rain barrels range from 45 to 65 gallons, which is ideal for watering plants or rinsing tools. If you live in an area with frequent rainfall or have a large garden, you might want to consider a larger barrel or a setup that allows multiple barrels to be connected.
✔️ Design and footprint: Consider where you’ll place the barrel in your yard. Flat-back designs are great for positioning against a wall, while urn or decorative styles blend better in smaller yards and visible areas. Make sure the barrel isn’t too bulky for your available space, as it can be visually imposing.
✔️ Material and durability: UV-stabilized polyethylene is the most common material and holds up well to outdoor elements. It won't fade, crack or rot. Look for BPA-free options if you plan to use the water around edible plants. Dark colors help reduce algae growth inside the tank.
✔️ Spigot and overflow: A high-quality spigot makes it easier to fill watering cans or connect a hose, compared to barrels that only include a built-in hose. An overflow valve or diverter ensures excess water is safely redirected during heavy rain.
✔️ Access and maintenance: Removable lids or wide openings allow for easier cleaning and checking for debris or mosquito buildup. Closed systems with mesh screens help keep bugs and leaves out.
✔️ Seasonal storage: In cold climates, choose a barrel that can be easily drained and stored during winter. Some models are more suitable for year-round use, so check your climate and barrel specifications.
Whether you're collecting rainwater for eco-conscious gardening or simply want to stretch your irrigation budget, the right rain barrel can be a practical and low-maintenance addition to your outdoor setup.
Why Trust Good Housekeeping?
This roundup was written by Timothy Dahl, a contributing writer for Good Housekeeping who has spent the past two decades reviewing home improvement products, tools and household essentials. As someone who enjoys gardening and values water conservation, he brings a practical, real-world approach to evaluating outdoor products.
Dan DiClerico has covered the home improvement market for more than two decades for brands like This Old House and Consumer Reports before joining the Good Housekeeping Institute in 2022. In his role as director of the Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab, Dan oversees the testing of all outdoor products, working closely with our team of writers and product analysts.
Timothy Dahl is an experienced writer and editor covering home improvement, DIY, and lifestyle topics for nearly 20 years. With a deep background in hands-on testing and reporting, he has reviewed and worked with hundreds of tools, products, and home innovations. Timothy's work has appeared in The New York Times, Wired, and Popular Mechanics, and he's the founder of Charles & Hudson. He specializes in making complex projects accessible and is passionate about empowering homeowners with clear, actionable guidance.
Having written thousands of product reviews and how-to articles on all aspects of home ownership, from routine maintenance to major renovations, Dan (he/him) brings more than 20 years of industry experience to his role as the director of the Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute. A one-time roofer and a serial remodeler, Dan can often be found keeping house at his restored Brooklyn brownstone, where he lives with his wife and kids.
Bala Bangles Review: A Trainer's Perspective
The Best King Size Mattresses
The Best Luggage for International Travel
The Best Solar-Powered Generators
